Eagle-eyed readers may have noticed that the ‘Magnificent Seven’ moniker does not come up in financial literature as much as it used to. The term became universally prevalent in the latter half of 2023 and remained a staple of US stock market talk well into the current year. Alas, Wall Street has largely retired the label over the past few months because the once tight-knit collection of companies has sadly stopped moving in unison, electing instead to fracture into distinct winners and losers.
A rough glance at the stock performance of each company since the start of Q3 more than adequately illustrates the story:
| Magnificent Seven | Change since July 1st (%) |
|---|---|
| Apple (AAPL) | +22% |
| Amazon (AMZN) | +12% |
| Alphabet (GOOG) | -21% |
| Meta (META) | +9% |
| Microsoft (MSFT) | +36% |
| Nvidia (NVDA) | -24% |
| Tesla (TSLA) | -9% |
Even the most delusional of statisticians would struggle to establish any kind of correlation in the above table. No one treats these companies as a single basket anymore, for obvious reasons.
AI spending is a major contributor to the divergence. A number of companies have been punished heavily this year for hurling money hand over fist at new data centres, while others, such as Apple, have been rewarded for their restraint. Investors are growing tired of watching tech giants set fire to billions of dollars in cash without concrete plans for revenue generation and have diverted their funds accordingly.
Outside of the Magnificent Seven itself, another factor contributing to the demise of the group was the recent addition of SpaceX to the Nasdaq. Elon Musk’s rocket venture immediately shot to a $2 trillion dollar valuation upon going public, placing it shoulder-to-shoulder with the major tech companies and presenting the dilemma of whether or not the group needed to be expanded. The Anthropic IPO later today further compounds the problem.
Investment Strategist Michael Hartnett, the person who first coined the ‘Magnificent Seven’, noted himself that the term had outlived its usefulness. No unified group stays at the top for long. Previous constructs such as ‘FAANG’ or ‘FANGMAN’ have likewise been relegated to the annals of history. The question is what comes next.
A remarkably boring answer is beginning to emerge. As the name implies, the S&P 500 includes 500 different companies. Rather than focusing on the seven discussed above, financial markets are simply turning their attention to the other 493 stocks that make up the index.
The ‘revenge of the boring stocks’ is sweeping through Wall Street, as investors pile into companies responsible for manufacturing toilet paper, toothbrushes and cans of soup. ‘Consumer staples’ is the best performing sector in the S&P 500 so far this quarter, followed by healthcare, utilities, financials and consumer discretionary. Not a GPU in sight. Yawn.
Costco (COST) and Coca-Cola (KO) are sitting at record highs after rising 20% and 14% respectively since the 1st of October. Procter and Gamble (PG) is up 17% over the same time frame. Church and Dwight (CHD), a company that makes baking soda and cat litter, is up 19% so far in Q4. Dull as dishwater but fantastic investments over the last couple of months.
Given the massive selloffs observed in some of the major tech companies this year, one could be forgiven for expecting to see the same wreckage plastered over the charts of the main indices, and yet, the S&P 500 is down a mere 6% from record highs. The reason for the relative stability is obvious: investors are not pulling out of the US stock market; they are simply rotating into the more overlooked aspects of it.
This becomes even more apparent when looking at price-to-earnings ratios. As a whole, the tech sector is currently trading at around 17x forward P/E, as low as the March 2020 Covid crash and far below historical norms. In contrast, consumer staples are trading at 25x forward P/E, while the likes of Costco and Walmart are trading between 40x and 50x.
Buying into such high ratios is obviously not ideal; the trade is simply very crowded due to the flight from big tech. Should inflation unexpectedly drop, or should the Fed suddenly decide that interest rate hikes are a bad idea after all, the trade is likely to unwind very quickly, possibly even violently. Until then, all hail the Magnificent 493.
About the Author
Lawrence J. came from a strong technical and engineering background before pivoting into a more financial role later on in his career. Always interested in international finance, Lawrence is experienced in both traditional markets as well as the emerging crypto markets. He now serves as the financial writer for RADEX MARKETS.
Reviewed by RADEX MARKETS
Risk Warning: Trading derivatives and leveraged products carries a high level of risk, including the risk of losing substantially more than your initial investment.
Operar con derivados y productos apalancados implica un alto riesgo y puede resultar en pérdidas superiores a su inversión inicial. Lea nuestros Términos y Condiciones (T&C) y la Declaración de Divulgación del Producto (PDS) antes de operar.
ABRIR CUENTA